Msbat's review of: The Writing Diet: Write Yourself Right-Size

Review of:
67%recommended
2.8
based on 8 ratings (67% recommend).
Saving vote...
Average: 2.8 (8 votes)
Mouse over the stars to rate.
The Writing Diet: Write Yourself Right-Size by Julia Cameron
From the bestselling author of The Artist's Way, a revolutionary diet plan: Use art to take off the pounds! Over the course of... read more



Review by:
msbat's picture
Posted on September 3, 2008 5:52 PM PDT
3 of 3 people found this review helpful:
1
Price Paid: $14.00
Recommends this product or service? No.
Not my cup of tea
100% found this helpful found this helpful
Saving...
Did you find this review helpful? YES NO

After reading the author’s other books, I discovered that Julia Cameron really knows her stuff. That is, her books really helped me get through some of my toughest creative blocks. And then I saw this: a book about writing…as a way to lose weight. It lost me there for a second. The author states that she is no diet expert, but found that in watching artists focus with her 12 week “program“ based on her previous work, they ended up losing weight. What a bonus! Though, I wonder; was the weight loss healthy? Or was it just that the artist couldn’t afford more than cup ‘o’ noodles? Hmm.

So basically, we’re taking the “starving artist” concept here a bit far, I think. What put me off the most is that she is no health expert. I don’t go to English class to get diet tips, sorry! So I really couldn’t take this book seriously. I loved The Artist’s Way, but I don’t think that I will be following the “writing diet” any time soon.

If you enjoyed this review, subscribe to our newsletter and we'll keep you updated with fresh new content.
Sort comments by: Most Recent | Threaded
SuzyQ's picture

I loved your review and found your analysis to be very accurate. Now don't you think it was "creative" of her to write a book about dieting? How innovative! I guess if someone writes a book, there will be others out there who will buy it, and Ms. Cameron did find an audience.

I do a lot of writing in my profession and the title of her book intrigued me, but it sounds like it is more about her own philosophy of what works for her than something that is healthy or endorsed by nutritionists. Your honest evaluation was much appreciated.


chelle123's picture

It is interesting to find that the author actually has no expertise in health. That does effect my wanting to read the advice in the book.


Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Login or register to post comments