Close

What Kind Of Person Are You…If You Believe in Republican Economic Policy?

NSchulman24's picture
Posted by NSchulman24 on October 15, 2008 12:26 PM PDT
100% recommended of users recommended this
Saving...
Recommend this? YES NO

money

As we prepare to head off to the voting booth on November 4th, it occurs to me that we are woefully uninformed as to the actual issues facing us, especially in terms of the economy. Instead both sides have subjected us to distracting attack ads and, as Democratic Nominee Senator Barack Obama put it, “Swift Boat Politics.” If we only listened to the commercials, here is what we would think: Alaska supplies 20% of our nation’s energy, McCain hates schools and wants to cut educational funding, Obama socializes with terrorists and McCain wants to cut social security benefits in half. What do all of these statements have in common? According to non-partisan factcheck.org, they are all false. And this is just the tip of the iceberg.

So what does the Republican Party REALLY believe?  And if you believe in these policies, what does that say about you? Are you an Extremely Loyal Social Darwinist with Blind Faith [EL-SD-BF] or an Eternally Optimistic Generous Soul who is a True Believer [EO-GS-TB]? Read below and figure out your Republican Personality Type.

SUPPLY SIDE ECONOMICS – The basis of Republican Economic policy falls on something known as “Supply Side Economics.”  The underlying tenets dictate that if you spend the money to produce more of a good, that will lower the price of that good and people will buy more of it, making a greater profit than would have been had at a higher price. This is then extended to the idea that if you cut taxes (see below) the people have more money and are going to be more willing to buy non-essential goods which will stimulate the economy.

If you believe in Supply Side Economics you are either a:

A)   Social Darwinist [SD]: Supply side economics are grounded in the idea that the hardest working among us will be the most successful. And the government must use incentives for the production of goods and services, such as tax cuts. From the farmer who spends all day in his fields to Nelson Rockefeller and Dale Carnegie, success is bred from hard work and dedication, not redistribution of wealth. 

OR…

B)   True Believer [TB]: Like McCain, you believe “The Fundamentals of Our Economy Are Strong.”  Many people have a hard time with this, especially with the government’s recent need to bail out AIG and parts of Lehman Brothers. Nevermind the fact that in the past 6 months the fall of Lehman Brothers, Bear Sterns and Merrill Lynch means that we lost 337 years of combined experience on Wall St. and as a result we’re in the middle of the worst Credit Crisis in American History. Nevertheless, there’s no substitute for faith – it can make all the difference in tough times. 

THE TAX POLICY:  As can be expected, the backbone of Supply Side Economics is the tax policy. The essence of Republican Tax policy is simple to understand – in a nutshell - “tax cuts pay for themselves.” McCain is also in favor of repealing the Alternative Minimum Tax - an outdated plan that was put in place to ensure that the wealthy weren’t able to claim too many deductions. The “AMT” has since become a burden on the middle class. 

If you believe in the Republican Tax Policy, you are a/an:

A)   Idealist [I]: For you, Americans should keep as many of their hard earned dollars as possible. American Revolutionary History is grounded in stories about rebelling against the English for unjust taxes. From the Boston Tea Party to cries of “No Taxation Without Representation” we were created to get out from under the grip of the tax man. So why not go with McCain’s big tax plan that involves cutting the corporate tax rate to 25% from the current 35%.

OR…

B)   Mathematics Monster [MM]: During the period between 2001-2006, using the same policies McCain is advocating, Tax revenues increased from $994 billion to $1.086 trillion. Sadly, when adjusting for inflation, that 9.25% increase actually becomes a 4.42% decrease in government funds. However, fancy math can make anything look good, so more power to you.

HEALTH CARE: Understanding McCain’s entire Health Care plan fully requires a lot of dedicated study. With this in mind, I think it’s important to focus on probably the most important element, eliminating the tax break that employees receive if they choose their employer’s health care plan. The expected result here is that this would free up employees to choose their own Health Plan separate from their employer, increasing competition and decreasing the cost of Health Insurance

If you believe in the Republican Health Care Policy, you are a:

A)   Free Market Fanatic[FMF]: McCain’s plan follows on the tenets of Adam Smith’s Invisible Hand: Competing for your business will mean lower prices and more incentives to sign up. Think of the Cereal Wars, except the service you get will be used less and is nowhere near as delicious.

OR…

B)    Generous Soul [GS] - As the late, great George Carlin once said “Think of how stupid the average person is and realize half of them are stupider than that.” In order for free markets to be effective, people have to make rational and informed decisions. Enough of us have trouble making rational decisions on what to eat for lunch, can we really be trusted to do the same for health care, or will the cheapest provider win out? You give people credit that they will figure it out and not spend their tax credit on filling up their gas tank.

THE ECONOMICS OF WAR: Everyone knows the basic differences between McCain and Obama in terms of the Iraq War: the Democrats want to start withdrawing troops and the Republicans want to stay in until “The Job Is Done.” But how does this relate to the economy? During 2008 The United States is spending 12 Billion Dollars every month in Iraq, and according to Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, the spending can be broken down to $5,000 every second. That makes this the second most expensive war ever, when adjusting for inflation, behind only World War II. It is estimated that by the end of the war we will have spent over 3 Trillion Dollars (yes, that’s $3,000,000,000,000.00).

If you believe in Republican War Spending, you are a/an:

A)   Extreme Loyalist [EL]. You believe victory in Iraq is imperative. There are many who believe we need to win at all costs, and that we can’t put a price on spreading democracy – the essence of what makes our country great.

OR...

B)   Eternally Optimistic [EO]: George W. Bush is the only President in US history to cut taxes during a major war. During World War II taxes were raised, Americans were encouraged to ration supplies, and Daylight Savings Time was implemented to save oil. Today?  Combining a 3 Trillion Dollar War with a 4.42% decrease in government tax income means you have to look at negative numbers. But things do turnaround…eventually.

Whenever election season comes through, it’s always kind of disturbing to see just how easily we ignore the key issues in favor of mud slinging and conspiracy theories. Thankfully, the Financial Crisis has brought economic issues to the forefront of voters’ minds, so maybe the issues WILL win out.  So instead of voting for McCain because Barack Obama’s middle name is Hussein, make an informed decision, and then embrace your Republican Personality Type. It will be so much easier to meet other Republicans with whom you could spend the rest of your life.

 

 

 

If you enjoyed this article, subscribe to our newsletter and we'll keep you updated with fresh new content.

I know that Mccain calls himself a republican, but if you compare him with actual conservative republicans that are fiscally conservative, he is nothing alike.
It makes me shudder that you are using Mccain as a benchmark for republicans.

I believe in the old guard of republicans, that believed that we need to shrink the size of government. The republicans that wanted to reduce taxes because our spending was under control. The republicans that wanted to keep us from going to war. The republicans that did not want to fund social welfare because they believe in people taking personal responsibility.

Thats that type of republican that I am, and that is also the reason I cannot vote for either Mccain or Obama. I believe both will simply maintain the status-quo and nothing will really change. Whether you vote for Mccain or Obama, both will want to spend a mountain of money, and increase the size of government. The only difference being subtle, such as... 'where should we spend this mountain of money'

Anonymous's picture

I support social welfare, with much more regualtion so that there will be less abuse of the program. I think those who have are somehwat responsible to help out those who do not have... would anyone feel that we are not at all responsible? A lot of what a person has is luck. Let's not get into race, genealogy and sex- all major contibuting factors. Not to mention place of origin, citizenship and where you live. The poor should not be ignored, that would be a most uncivilized society...and this kind of comment is what gives the Repub's a bad name with many people. I am (mostly) on the Repub. side, but I am far more democratic when it comes to social welfare it seems...

Anonymous's picture

"Idealist," "Generous soul," "Eternally optimistic," ...guess I'm a republican? I registered as an independent precisely because of these gray zones. I definitely believe in small govt. However, there are still too many social inequities that make that a distant reality. I'm a "true believer" that the fundamentals of our economy are sound. However, whether or not they are "strong"/ effective depends on the latitude within the market to adjust to changing times.

Amanda's picture

I came out as SD-I-FMF-EL motto "I work hard for my money, and I love my country and want it to stay the 'heck' out of my way"

This race was not Republican v/s democrat this was Democrat v/s Marxist.

True republican policy would be cut government programs till output is as small as input, then cut both more. We believe it's better for the government to get out of welfare and leave that to charities because you can never regulate efficiency but you can and always do build inefficiency into regulations, sometimes on purpose as a necessary evil. We believe America is the greatest place in the world because by and large you can do what you want, including becoming who you want, because it depends solely on you and your choices.

Anonymous's picture

While it's lovely sentiment to believe that our outcomes depend solely on "you and your choices" that completely ignores the fact that societal inequalities are inevitable. While Smith's invisible hand works perfectly in an ideal society, this is not an ideal society. You may believe I detailed marxism instead of republican policy, but it was all taken straight from McCain's website itself.

NSchulman24's picture

Another awesome article. It's neat to take this side by side with your democratic article. Your articles seem to be impartial to either party, which makes them better to read, as they don't tell you to believe in something particular, just give you lots of information.

KnitsofLove's picture