Close

Michael Phelps Makes A Deal With Tony The Tiger? That’s Grrrrreat!

Sheamus's picture
Posted by Sheamus on August 27, 2008 12:26 PM PDT
100% recommended of users recommended this
Saving...
Recommend this? YES NO

So, Michael Phelps, fresh off of his record-haul of eight gold medals at the 2008 Beijing Olympics, has signed a deal with Kellogg’s to appear on boxes of Frosted Flakes.

Heavens, no, says the NY Daily News and nutritionists around the world.

I say, it’s actually a smart move on his part. This is a good thing, especially for children.

Traditionally, athletes looking to spread the word about the benefits of exercise and a healthy diet have made their deals with Wheaties. The cereal was first introduced in 1924, and began its association with sports in 1933, sponsoring radio broadcasts of minor league baseball teams. Soon thereafter, Wheaties began to market itself as ‘The Breakfast Of Champions’.

The slogan stuck. In 1958, Olympic athlete Bob Richards became the first of seven spokespersons for the Wheaties brand. Walter Payton, Chris Evert, Michael Jordan and Tiger Woods would feature in later years.

The Wheaties brand seemed an obvious choice for Phelps. So why make the deal with the Devil – aka Tony the Tiger – instead?

Could it have been the money? Let’s not be naïve about this. I’m pretty sure Kellogg’s offered a sweeter deal (if you’ll excuse the pun). I’ve yet to see any discussion about exactly what kind of package Phelps has received but despite all of his success, swimming doesn’t exactly pay the bills. First and foremost he’d have been looking to cash-in. You can’t blame him for that – I’d say he’s earned it.

But that doesn’t mean he’s taken the money over common sense or decency. And here’s why – all cereals are, when you get right down it, basically the same, certainly when it comes to calories. An average-sized bowl of Wheaties (about 30 grams) has 110 calories, 1 gram of fat, 3 grams of protein and 4 grams of sugar. A similar-sized bowl of Frosted Flakes has 114 calories, 0.1 grams of fat, 1.3 grams of protein, and here’s the kicker, 12 grams of sugar.

This is the part the nutrionists don’t like. "I would rather see him promoting Fiber One. I would rather see him promoting oatmeal. I would even rather see him promoting Cheerios,” says Rebecca Solomon, of the Mount Sinai Medical Center. And it’s true that those alternatives have less sugar than Frosted Flakes.

But here’s the thing – kids won’t eat Fiber One. Kids won’t eat oatmeal. And most kids won’t eat Cheerios – without putting sugar on top.

And most of all – kids won’t eat Wheaties. Kids hate Wheaties. Phelps hates Wheaties. And with good reason – Wheaties suck.

Kids, meantime, love Frosted Flakes. And I’m going to let you in on a little secret. We might have to keep this amongst ourselves for a bit. If you feel the need to share with a friend, whisper it real, real quiet, otherwise you’ll have to fend off all manner of dirty looks, tsks and raised eyebrows from the folks at the next table.

Sugar doesn’t make people fat.

Sugar isn’t bad. Sugar isn’t ‘evil’. Sugar isn’t some kind of monster. Sugar is… sugar. In and of itself it’s a harmless little white rock that tastes kinda good.

Sugar doesn’t make people put on weight – inactivity does. People make people fat.

That’s right. Legend has it that Michael Phelps consumes eight to twelve thousand calories per day. Legend also has it that Michael Phelps works out for six to eight hours per day.

If a bowl of cereal has 110 calories, it doesn’t really matter where those calories come from. A calorie is a calorie is a calorie, certainly when it comes to weight control.

Calories are a measure of energy. If you expend more energy than you consume you will lose weight. If you consume more energy than you expend you will gain weight. If you keep things about the same, your weight will stay where it is.

It’s that simple. A daily bowl of cereal – any cereal – won’t do your child any harm at all. Sure, if your kids love Wheaties, then let them eat Wheaties. But if the only cereal they’ll eat is Frosted Flakes, wouldn’t you like the guy starting out at them from the box to be Michael Phelps?

Consider the math. How many boxes of Frosted Flakes are sold for every box of Wheaties? It’s probably in the thousands. Doesn’t it make more sense for a million kids to wake up to the image of Phelps and everything he represents than a few thousand?

I say, put Phelps’ image on every box of chocolate frosted sugar bombs made by every cereal manufacturer in the world. I say put Phelps on packets of Oscar Meyer bacon. I say put Phelps on hot dog buns, cookies, pancakes, sausage patties, Pringles, Tater Tots, Twinkies and Coca Cola.

I say, when you open a Hershey’s bar, Phelps should be smiling up at you from the chocolate.

Go ahead and enjoy your food, kids. That’s what Michael Phelps wants. Because maybe – just maybe – when you’re done, you’ll go outside and play.

Now, you tell me – isn’t that worth a little sugar?

If you enjoyed this article, subscribe to our newsletter and we'll keep you updated with fresh new content.

eh...it kinda does matter that the calories come from sugar in this breakfast cereal aimed at kids. It is well known that sugar provides a spike of energy followed by a down period, unlike more 'fibery' (complex carbs) foods which are slower burning, releasing their energy over a period of time.

Your argument about weight change being a factor of energy intake/expenditure is a correct and refreshing one. Kids however should be encouraged to eat more complex carbs for breakfast for two very good reasons:

1. The comedown period after the spike in energy is as a result of excessive amounts of glucose (sugar) being removed from the blood, causing low blood sugar. As the brain need energy to work, its function will be impaired by this effect within around 1-2 hours after consuming a sugary meal - usually correspoding witht the time the child arrives at school - leading to a not very productive morning, educationally speaking.

2.Secondly, the low blood sugar levels cause the child to seek out food that will raise their levels again. Therefore at break they will consume more sugary foods and drinks. This cycle will be repeated throughout the day causing the child to go through periods of hyperactivity followed by intense energy lows, neither of which will be good for their bodies or their brains.

Just my 2 cents, you make a good point about caloric balance, but food intake is about more than just calories, especially at breakfast

Anonymous's picture

You've missed the point. Kids are going to eat Frosted Flakes no matter whether you, the government or anyone else thinks they should or not. If they're going to eat them anyway, then you couldn't have a better person on the front of the box - judging them if you will - than Michael Phelps. Hence, as the article says, why that's worth 'a little sugar'.

Anonymous's picture

I actually think this is great. I never ate Wheaties, and none of my friends did, none of my kids do. What a better way to show kids what can be achieved then on something you know they will see. I say kudos belong to Phelps for making this decision. Sweeter deal or not.

Anonymous's picture

i love wheaties and never liked frosted flakes.
too sweet.

Anonymous's picture

if I was a mom, i'd be pretty disappointed.
I'd keep my kids out of the grocery store until the campaign was over.

Anonymous's picture

Has Tony the Tiger ever been taken off the Frosted Flakes box just a little debate we had going on at my job.

Anonymous's picture

if kids "like chocolate frosted sugar bombs, and will eat them instead of bran gravel crunch no matter what you do", then CFSB inc is pretty stupid to shell out money for endorsements.

Anonymous's picture

I agree mostly to what you're saying in this blog. I do agree that kids will eat what they want to eat, no matter who is on the packaging. Also, if Phelps really likes Frosted Flakes, let him do whatever he likes. Of course, it would have been nicer to have him on a box that's a little healthier, but it's not that big of a deal. He could have done a lot worse than Frosted Flakes. Is it that big of a deal that he signed with Frosted Flakes? I don't think so.

euroni's picture