How to Have an Unconventional Thanksgiving

lkoehne's picture
Posted by lkoehne on November 22, 2008 5:07 PM PST
Topic: Happiness
100% recommended of users recommended this
Saving...
Recommend this? YES NO

With relative lack of materialism and heaping helpings of gratitude and human connectedness, Thanksgiving is the “poster holiday” for the personal growth industry. Everywhere I turn there are messages from coaches and self-help gurus are reminding us to give thanks.

Nice sentiments, but let’s talk turkey for a minute…

I don’t feel terribly thankful at Thanksgiving. I feel stressed! Thanksgiving is filled with unattainable expectations. Not only is it “my” holiday – meaning I host assorted family and friends that I wish to entertain perfectly – it’s the event that marks the start of many weeks of martha-stewart-inspired holiday frenzy.

Knowing that for many of us Thanksgiving is filled with tension, I’m not here to tell you to be grateful (I did that weeks ago!) Instead I wish to remind you that you have a choice in the matter. Instead of a stress fest, let this be the year you break the mold.

To start, here are 3 ways you can have an unconventional holiday:

Dare to be less than perfect.

If you are hosting this year’s Thanksgiving feast, beware! The need for perfection drives many to the dreadful fate of not enjoying their own party. What’s the point of surrounding yourself with family, friends and food if you cannot enjoy a morsel?

Every year I stress about getting all kinds of complicated dishes on the table simultaneously, hot and beautifully garnished. Never once have I managed to do this. It’s time for me to realize that a simple salad can be beautiful and delicious (and made well ahead) and green beans actually taste better at room temperature.

The first step for overcoming the yoke of perfection is to admit you need help. Then, let others help you! In fact, don’t just wait for outside offers of help: crack the whip and delegate. ASK your nieces and nephews to set the table. ASK Aunt Sally to bring her delicious cornbread.

This is how my husband started frying our turkeys in the backyard – a tradition that lends an air of adventure and danger to our festivities. I’m relieved of a responsibility, and it turns out that this is really fun for him! Oh, and now that the oven’s free, I’m a step closer to my nirvana of simultaneous hot dishes.

Party hardy.

News flash! Holiday celebrations are supposed to be fun! Whether you host the day or not, think about what would make the gathering a joyful party. For some this might mean giving thanks and sharing stories of gratitude around the table. For others it’s games and movement – Wii bowling? A walk around the neighborhood after dinner? Others crave stimulating discussion and debate. No matter your leaning, create circumstances that enable your fun.

A friend of mine sets up a Bloody Mary bar on Thanksgiving morning and guests take turns competing to make the best concoction (prizes are given!) Writer Keith Ferrazi suggests seating people close together and even changing seats half way through dinner as a way to encourage genuine connection and conversation.

This year experiment with your party. (Here’s a link to more ideas for hosting an unconventional dinner party.)

Break the rules.

Part of what makes holidays so stressful are the unwritten rules that go along with them. We follow our habitual traditions, roles and conventions without stopping to consider whether these serve us or make us happy.

Your rule breaking may manifest in an unconventional menu: A vegetarian meal or bucking tradition completely … Burritos anyone?

But Thanksgiving is also an opportunity to break the habits and unexamined rules that might be keeping you from feeling your full dose of holiday gratitude. Perhaps this year you delegate cooking duties completely to free yourself from the role of accommodating caretaker for everyone else. Or you might expand your guest list to include a number of your dearest friends, and essentially redefine “family” at your table.

If you tackle your perfectionism, make room for joy and celebration, and boldly question the unwritten rules behind your holiday habits, you might find more honest-to-goodness gratitude creeping in. I guess Thanksgiving is the perfect self help holiday after all!

Happy Thanksgiving!

If you enjoyed this blog entry, subscribe to our newsletter and we'll keep you updated with fresh new content.
Sort comments by: Most Recent | Threaded
Aspian's picture

Wow! Amazing thoughts on how to truly be thankful and enjoy Thanksgiving - or any stressful holiday! Thanks for a great post!


missfunkadilly's picture

Cute article. The holidays really are very stressful. And as a host, it is hard to stop yourself and remember that you're supposed to be having fun too and you don't have to make everything perfect.


KnitsofLove's picture

Awesome article! It's hard to remember that you're supposed to have fun and enjoy things, not just run around crazy. This is a great place to read, take a breath, and remember that!


lkoehne's picture

Thanks for the support! You know how we teach what we need to learn? Well, I had an awesome Thanksgiving this year. I wrote just what I needed to hear!


euroni's picture

I think it was a good article for me to read, but it's hard to follow. For me and my family, it's all about "prefection" and following tradiiton. It was a good read for me since this is a type of Thanksgiving that I never experience, but I know that I cannot follow this. However, I do find joy in our traditions.


Bizilbur's picture

Heh, I've been having unconventional thanksgivings (and other holidays) for years. But your ideas seem like they'll cause less people to look at you like crazy. Plus this advice can apply to other holidays too.


chelle123's picture

What a great blog post! I specially liked the points you made on perfectionism. I so see myself there. I'll take your advice.


heathcole's picture

Great blog! I would also suggest potlucks for all holiday feasts. That way all the pressure is not on one person and everyone can help to pay and cook the meal. It gives the host more time to relax and actually enjoy the meal and the family/friend gathering. Also, as a vegetarian, try Thanksgiving sans turkey! Another great thing to do is to not have a Thanksgiving feast at all, but rather donate your time as a family at a local soup kitchen helping others less fortunate celebrate!


lkoehne's picture

I am so pleased that many have found this post useful. I got some more practice over the Christmas Holiday too. (A spontaneous popcorn fight with my 5 year old on Christmas evening will be one of my lasting holiday memories!)

Stretching myself further with "party therapy" I have also begun to have -- gasp! -- spontaneous dinner parties. We invite friends over and give ourselves only about an hour to prepare. This forces me to cut through the priorities rather quickly: food, yes...wine, yes...no, the draperies do not need to be vacuumed! And after I get over the horror of the house being less than perfect (and my friends, of course, still like me despite that) I have a incredibly good time.

Hope you, too, will continue to stretch, love, learn and party in 2009!


Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.
You are not logged in, so your comment will be posted as "Anonymous." Log in or register now!